Russell Cruse
  • Home
  • The Rothko Room
    • Writing The Rothko Room
    • The Rothko Room Characters
    • The Council
    • The Real Rothko Room
    • Rothko Room Covers
    • The Rothko Room Music
    • The Rothko Room Puzzles
    • Locations in The Rothko Room
    • Waifs & Strays >
      • Churchill
      • The Origin of The Council
      • The First Meeting of The Council
  • Books
    • Head Count
    • The Circling Song
  • Weblog
  • Comments
  • Ukulele Stuff
  • Weblog Selections

I Know What I Think I Mean Because I Told Me So

29/5/2011

2 Comments

 
  Do you ever have songs running through your head? Songs that you may not even like but which are lodged (mercifully briefly, for the most part) in your “read only memory” and which remain stubbornly resistant to deletion?
No?
All right, how about this:
When you read, do you “hear” the words in your head as you see them?
No?

Well, I wonder if you realise that there are those of us who experience both of those things and take them very much for granted?

As I understand it, the term, “inner narrative” has two strands. The first is the information we hold in our minds about our own lives and experiences – our own “story”. It consists not only of memories but of our interpretations of events that have occurred to others we know, however tangentially. An example might the popular game of “...where were you when...” in which common matters of human import (of which the best modern example is the destruction of the World Trade Centre towers) are recalled in the context of our own lives.

The second strand concerns the “conversation” we have with ourselves throughout the day – our inner “voice” - that interprets and analyses our experiences and helps us to make sense of and compartmentalise the things that happen during our waking lives. If you talk out loud to yourself, you are also likely to form memories in this narrative manner.

If you were bemused by the first couple of questions in this article, then the idea of an inner voice may be as bizarre and difficult to understand as the lack of one is to me. Although I've long known that I am a slow reader, I had not realised that some people, those who read extremely quickly, can by-pass the inner voice on which others like me rely in order to make sense of what we read. I have often envied those who are able to read quickly with complete understanding and so, I'm somewhat gratified to learn that with this ability, there sometimes comes a lack of “inner narrative”.

Of course, this schadenfreude may well be as misplaced as it is shameful but there is evidence that an inner narrative has been an essential aid to human evolution, allowing the possiblity of abstract thought to develop.

But far more gratifying than this, is that it might indicate that all those people who champion the “stripped down” method of story writing may suffer from the same affliction. For one thing, it would account for their rather peculiar aversion to adjectives. And, if anything even more so, adverbs.

Allow me to explain.

The ancient Egyptians famously had no adjectives to describe colour. They understood that colours existed but had no use for words to differentiate between them. Nor, of course, did their written language which, being pictographic, also made it difficult to express abstract concepts. In fact, I understand the Dani people of New Guinea fall into the same category, understanding only that some hues are light and others dark.  As a society advance, so the theory goes, it develops the abstract thinking necessary for social, cultural, technological and scientific development. 

If, as a writer, you have little use for adjectives, you might want to ask why and don't simply respond by reference to works on technique. Try to explain why you don't particularly like using them.

As for adverbs, I'm going to finish with a theory of my own. Ahem.

The inner voice is essential to reify abstract thought - this is one of the reasons that talking therapies can be so effective.  Adverbs are the way in which we opine about motive and emotive mannerisms. If someone performs an act, it helps to understand it by reference to the manner in which it was performed. I shall take a prosaic example. The verb “to smile”. It can be described in many ways and that description will determine the meaning of that smile. The lack of an adverbial modifier compromises meaning. It also serves my prejudice in these matters to believe that this unwillingness to emote points to a somewhat psychopathic personality.

This will be my new counter to the Swainians et al.
2 Comments
Poppet link
28/5/2011 09:47:15 pm

I love your last sentence! And I agree!

Reply
Tee link
29/5/2011 05:38:44 pm

Seriously fascinating article Russell.
Tee

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Follow this blog

    RSS Feed

    UK Amazon Kindle Forum's group-authors-bookshelf book montage
    UK Amazon Kindle Forum 222 members
    Somewhere else for those who hang around on the official Amazon Kindle Forum to slouch around.

    Our group-authors-bookshelf shelf



    View this group on Goodreads »

    Archives

    November 2015
    August 2014
    May 2014
    March 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    June 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011

    Categories

    All
    A Clockwork Orange
    Alice Cooper
    American Literature
    Andrew Mitchell
    Anthony Burgess
    Blogging
    Book Cover
    Cover Design
    Crossword
    Eastwood
    Editing
    Emperor's New Clothes
    English
    English Language
    Films
    Frazier
    Gary Barlow
    Godfrey Bloom
    Homeless
    Homeless Man
    Homophones
    Internet Down
    John Farris
    Julian Fellowes
    Kelsey Grammer
    Language
    Left-Wing
    Literary Fiction
    Lord Mcalpine
    Mark Rothko
    Nomophilia
    Nomophobia
    Patrick O'Brian
    Pleb
    Politics
    Prejudice
    Pretentious
    Promoting Literature
    Publishing
    Raimi
    Reliance On Mobile Phones
    Richard Matheson
    Self-publishing
    Semiotics
    Spin
    Twitter
    Without The Internet
    Writing


Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.